Mitigating Contract Risks: What Businesses Need to Know About Material Breach

Mitigating Contract Risks: What Businesses Need to Know About Material Breach

Written By
Joy Cunanan
Updated on
July 22, 2024
Reading time:

Despite the countless hours given to negotiations, complex paperwork, and building trust, a business relationship can completely change and go down the drain if one party fails to deliver what they have promised. This is what is called a breach of contract, with material breaches being one of the most damaging and posing a significant risk to the future of your business — a problem that no business wants to face. 

In this article, we’ll go through what a material breach is, how they are defined and dealt with in the real world of business, and how they ensure your business stays protected from one of the most significant problems in contract law. 

Get regular updates about contract management and digital transformation!
Thank you!
You email has been subscribed to our newsletter.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Understanding Breach of Contract

In the realm of business, a contract is the very foundation of any business relationship or transaction. They represent legally binding agreements between multiple parties, outlining the terms and conditions mutually accepted. Nevertheless, what transpires when one party fails to fulfill its end of the bargain? This is where the concept of a breach of contract emerges, unfurling a cascade of potential challenges.

A breach of contract transcends mere inconveniences, morphing into a legal predicament with far-reaching implications. It signifies a failure to uphold the obligations and responsibilities embedded within a contract, consequently inflicting significant losses and jeopardising the hard-earned reputation of a business.

Types of Breach of Contract

When multiple parties enter into a legally binding agreement, they expect each other to fulfil their contractual obligations. A breach of contract occurs when one party fails to do so, and it can manifest in various forms:

  1. Minor Breach

A minor breach takes place when a party fails to fulfil a contractual obligation that is not crucial to the overall agreement. An example of a minor breach would be a delivery arriving a day later than expected, without affecting the ultimate outcome of the project.

  1. Fundamental Breach

A fundamental breach materialises when one party violates a critical aspect of the contract, thereby rendering it impracticable for the other party to carry out their obligations. A prime example would be a supplier failing to deliver the goods altogether, signifying a breach of fundamental importance.

  1. Anticipatory Breach

An anticipatory breach occurs when one party expressly communicates their refusal or incapacity to fulfil their contractual obligations prior to the predetermined deadline. For instance, if a contractor proactively notifies a client in advance about their inability to complete a project within the mutually agreed-upon timeframe, it signifies an anticipatory breach.

  1. Material Breach

Among the diverse range of breach types, material breach stands as the paramount concern due to its profound significance and far-reaching consequences. A material breach occurs when one party fails to fulfill a critical obligation explicitly delineated in the contractual agreement, thereby rendering it utterly impossible for the other party to realise the expected advantages.

For instance, let us consider a situation where a company hires a software developer to meticulously craft a tailor-made program, then encounters the complete absence of any delivered product. In this instance, the failure to fulfill the fundamental obligation constitutes a material breach, often leading to the pursuit of legal remedies such as seeking compensatory damages or even contemplating the termination of the contract.

The Significance of Material Breach

Material breaches are widely regarded as the gravest form of contract violation, inflicting substantial harm upon the party that did not breach the agreement. Such breaches transpire when one party fails to fulfill a crucial obligation explicitly outlined in the contract, thereby rendering it impracticable for the other party to attain the anticipated benefits.

In essence, a material breach irreversibly fractures the contractual framework, leaving the non-breaching party with no recourse but to pursue legal remedies in order to restore justice and enforce their rights.

Case Study: Material Breach and the Fallout for a Major Asia-Based Tech Company

An actual instance illustrating a substantial breach of contract occurred in Asia with the bankruptcy of Skymark Airlines, Japan's largest discount carrier, in 2011. Skymark had placed an order for six new Airbus A380 aircraft valued at $1.7 billion. However, Airbus terminated the order claiming that Skymark made it clear that it was unable to meet “its contractual obligations.” 

According to a Reuters article, Airbus responded by canceling the order and initiating legal action against Skymark, seeking compensation for breach of contract and associated damages. The lawsuit contended that Skymark's material breach inflicted considerable financial losses upon Airbus and negatively impacted its reputation within the aviation industry.

The repercussions stemming from Skymark's material breach were substantial. The airline was compelled to file for bankruptcy, while Airbus incurred financial losses and suffered reputational harm. This case serves as a poignant reminder of the criticality of honouring contractual commitments, especially in significant business transactions entailing substantial financial investments.

Legal Implications & Consequences of Material Breach

A breach of contract is not a mere inconvenience; it has legal ramifications and can result in severe consequences. It entails a failure to fulfill the obligations and responsibilities outlined in the contract, which can lead to significant financial losses and reputational harm to a business.

Here are some of the consequences associated with material breach:

  1. Taking Legal Action

When a significant breach occurs, the injured party has the option to pursue legal recourse against the breaching party. Legal action may involve initiating a lawsuit to seek appropriate remedies, such as compensation for damages or even the rescission of the contract itself. 

Additionally, the injured party may explore the avenue of specific performance, compelling the breaching party to fulfill their contractual obligations as originally agreed upon.

  1. Seeking Damages

The party that has been negatively affected by the breach is entitled to pursue adequate compensation for the damages they have incurred. These damages may encompass both tangible consequences, such as financial setbacks and lost profits, as well as intangible repercussions like missed business prospects and consequential losses. The exact amount of compensation granted is contingent upon a careful assessment of the unique circumstances surrounding the breach and the provisions set forth in the contractual agreement.

  1. Impact on Reputation 

Material breaches can significantly tarnish the reputation of the party that fails to fulfill its contractual commitments. This repercussion becomes particularly pronounced when the breach garners widespread attention or generates adverse publicity.

 In addition to the legal and financial ramifications, the breaching party may suffer enduring harm to their brand image and strained relationships with clients and partners.

  1. Termination of the Contract

In instances where the breach is of substantial magnitude, or in other words, very serious, the affected party reserves the right to terminate the contract unilaterally. This course of action carries consequential implications for the breaching party, including the potential loss of projected revenues and other contractually stipulated benefits.

How to Minimise the Risk of Material Breach

Protecting your business against the potential ramifications of a material breach is paramount to its success and growth, as it shields you from potential legal entanglements, financial setbacks, as well as damage to your reputation. To mitigate the risk of material breaches effectively, consider implementing the following strategies:

  1. Thoroughly assess and negotiate contracts.

Take a meticulous approach when reviewing and negotiating contracts. Carefully analyse all terms, conditions, and clauses to ensure they align with your business objectives and minimise potential areas of dispute.

  1. Clearly define and outline contractual obligations.

Establish unambiguous, well-defined obligations for all parties involved. Ensure that each party's responsibilities are explicitly outlined, leaving no room for misinterpretation or ambiguity.

  1. Implement robust due diligence procedures.

Conduct thorough background checks on potential contracting parties in order to verify their credibility, financial stability, and track record to minimise the risk of entering into agreements with unreliable or high-risk entities.

  1. Seek legal counsel from professionals in law.

Engaging in services of competent and well-trained legal professionals who specialise in contract law will significantly help you navigate the intricacies of contractual obligations, identify potential risks, and develop strategies to mitigate them effectively.

  1. Maintain effective communication channels for all parties.

Establish open lines of communication and foster transparent dialogue with all parties involved throughout the contract lifecycle. Regularly engage in constructive discussions, addressing any concerns promptly to maintain a healthy working relationship.

  1. Monitor and track the performance of contracts from end to end.

Continuously monitor the performance of all parties involved in the contract. Implement robust tracking mechanisms to ensure adherence to timelines, quality standards, and other contractual provisions.

  1. Implement risk mitigation measures.

Proactively identify potential risks and develop contingency plans to minimise their impact on your business. Consider incorporating contractual provisions, such as indemnification clauses and dispute resolution mechanisms, to address potential breaches and resolve disputes efficiently.

  1. Regularly review and update contracts.

Keep contracts under regular review and adapt them to changing business dynamics or regulatory requirements. Periodically assess their relevance and effectiveness, making necessary amendments to align with evolving circumstances. 

By adopting these proactive measures, businesses can significantly reduce the risk of material breaches and safeguard their interests, fostering a secure and conducive environment for successful contractual engagements.

Safeguard Your Business From Material Breaches With Lexagle

The issue of material breach carries significant weight and demands the utmost attention from businesses. Its consequences extend beyond legal ramifications and financial losses, encompassing the potential tarnishing of a company's reputation. To proactively mitigate the risk of material breach, businesses must adopt a series of crucial measures.

At Lexagle, we comprehend the gravity of material breaches and are well-equipped to assist businesses in implementing these proactive steps. Our expertise and services can guide businesses in fortifying themselves against the potential ramifications of material breach, thereby upholding their reputation in the competitive marketplace.

Take action before it is too late. We encourage businesses to be proactive in their approach and schedule a demo with us at Lexagle to explore how our platform can streamline the contract management process, optimise business operations, and strengthen your overall risk management strategy.

Mitigating Contract Risks: What Businesses Need to Know About Material Breach
Joy Cunanan
Joy is the Digital Transformation Manager at Lexagle. As a marketing professional in the Tech and B2B industry for over seven years, she is always on the lookout for the next best solution in the ever-changing online world. With a passion for helping businesses thrive and optimize operations, she shares her expertise in the power of contract lifecycle management and its capacity of easing the contracting process for busy organizations worldwide.

Related Articles

Eagle Logo mask background

Streamline your contract management process with Lexagle and accelerate your business.

Contact us for a short demo today, and to discuss how Lexagle can best fit your organization’s needs!